top of page

#163 Your Cash Flow is Wrong

Writer: Grant Wiese
Grant Wiese
Oct 26
5 min read
Cash Flow is Wrong

SW Financial Literacy


Your Cash Flow is Wrong

And probably only hurting you


I've talked to several loan underwriters who have wanted to completely eliminate a cash flow projection from loan decisions, either for a line of credit or for real estate purchases.


Why would they do that?


A farmer's projection is often so wrong or inconsistent compared to how the operation is actually run. Too many projections are farmers lying to themselves. They think prices will go higher and estimated expenses will go lower on every single projection, every single year.


Reality is found on your balance sheet, not in the cash flow statement.


The Lies We Tell Ourselves

Rarely do I believe a cash flow projection is accurate unless it has a breakdown by field and is not using the same chemical and fertilizer expense per acre across all fields. Only accurate cash flows with real expenses by field are worth using for decision making. Otherwise, the balance sheet is a true measure of how the operation is doing.


Let's look at a 1,500-acre corn operation. The farmer is projecting a 215-bushel yield at $4.00 corn. That's $1,290,000 in gross revenue.


But the cash flow doesn't work. Expenses are too high, and there isn't enough money left over to make the payments. What happens next?


Well, the farmer knows they have some pretty good ground and decides to bump the projected yield to 225 bushels. That's another $60,000 in revenue without spending another dollar.


Still not quite enough.


Let's assume corn prices are going to improve by harvest. Instead of $4.00 corn, let's use $4.25. That's another $84,375 in projected revenue. Just like that, we found $144,375 in additional income without making a single change to the operation.


We didn't buy cheaper fertilizer, negotiate better rent, improve our marketing, or find a way to reduce equipment expenses. We just changed a couple of numbers on a spreadsheet.

The cash flow now works, and everyone can feel good about the projection. But did we actually fix anything?


Your cash flow is wrong. This is the problem I see with cash flows. We can manipulate the numbers to show exactly what we want to see. And if the lender needs a positive cash flow to approve the loan, there is a temptation to keep making changes until the numbers work.


That doesn't mean the operation will actually generate that income.


The Balance Sheet Doesn't Lie

While increasing expenses or making changes to the cash flow can help your top-end yield, that isn't always the best decision for you financially. The balance sheet is the only accurate way to know how you are progressing year over year financially. If net worth gains cannot be found there, then they did not happen on the cash flow.


Let's look at another example.


A farmer starts the year with $500,000 in working capital, $1.8 million in total debt, and $3 million in net worth.


Twelve months later, the farmer has $300,000 in working capital, $2 million in total debt, and $2.95 million in net worth.


Year 1

Year 2

Working capital

$500,000

$300,000

Total debt

$1,800,000

$2,000,000

Net worth

$3,000,000

$2,950,000

The farmer might tell you they had a pretty good year. They raised a good crop, paid their bills, and maybe even bought a piece of equipment. But look at what actually happened.


Working capital dropped $200,000. Total debt increased $200,000. Net worth declined $50,000.


Where did all the money go? That is the question the balance sheet forces you to answer. And here is where things get even more interesting.


What if that same farmer's net worth had increased $200,000 instead? Would that automatically mean the operation had a profitable year? Not necessarily.


What if the farmland they owned appreciated by $300,000 during that same period? Now you have a farmer who grew their net worth by $200,000 but actually lost $100,000 elsewhere in the operation.


This is why you need to understand the difference between earned equity growth and appreciation. Farmland values going higher can make a balance sheet look fantastic, even when the operation itself is struggling to generate a profit. I'm not saying appreciation is bad. I love seeing land values go higher. But appreciation doesn't mean you're doing a good job managing the operation, which is why we don't show land appreciation on our balance sheets. To find your true profits and losses.


And your balance sheet needs to be accurate. If you're inflating equipment values, leaving off liabilities, or overvaluing inventory, you're just doing the same thing to your balance sheet that you were doing to your cash flow.


Why Do Lenders Still Use Cash Flows?

If cash flow projections are so unreliable, why do lenders continue to use them?


Because they do serve a purpose.


I want to see actual expenses from your operation. I want to know what you spent on fertilizer, chemicals, seed, rent, repairs, and family living. I want to know what grain is already contracted and what grain is still exposed to the market. This helps me determine if your losses are coming from poor production, excessive debt levels, inefficient input expenses, high cash rent, or various other reasons.


I don't want to see the same expense per acre across every field just because it makes the spreadsheet easier to put together.


And I certainly don't want to see an operation projecting higher prices and lower expenses every single year without a legitimate reason for those changes.


A good cash flow should be updated throughout the year as things change. If fertilizer costs come in higher than expected, update it. If you sell grain for less than projected, update it. If you buy a piece of equipment that wasn't in the original plan, update it.


The value of a cash flow isn't that you can make it positive. The value is knowing what is actually happening in your operation mid-year and using that information to make year-end decisions on the fly.

The Three-Year Test

Here's what I want you to do.


Pull out your last three year-end balance sheets. If you don't have them, that's a problem in itself, and you need to start putting them together.


Look at three things.

1. Working capital. Has it increased or decreased? Are you building cash and liquidity, or are you slowly draining your checking account and operating note to keep the operation moving?


2. Total debt. Are you paying down debt, or does the total amount owed continue to increase? I'm not saying that increasing debt is always bad, especially if you're purchasing productive assets, but you need to understand why it's happening.


3. Net worth. Is your net worth growing? And more importantly, is that growth coming from actual profits retained in the operation, or is it simply appreciation on land and equipment?

Look at the trend over three years, not just one.


One bad crop year or one large purchase can make a balance sheet look worse temporarily. But if you're consistently losing working capital, increasing debt, and relying on appreciation to grow your net worth, something needs to change.


I want you to become the financial expert of your own operation. Not your banker. Not your accountant. You.


You should know where your working capital stands, how much debt you're carrying, and whether the decisions you're making are actually increasing your wealth. A cash flow projection is a useful tool when done correctly. It can help you plan purchases, understand payment timing, and make decisions before problems arise.


But a projection is still just a projection.


Your balance sheet shows what actually happened.

If your cash flow says you're making money, but your balance sheet says you're getting poorer, which one are you going to believe?

If you don't know whether your balance sheet is getting stronger or weaker, it's time to find out.


Head over to www.farmbalancesheet.com and put together an updated balance sheet for your operation. Track your working capital, debt, and net worth so you can see whether you're actually making financial progress.


Stop guessing. Know your numbers.


Have a great week!


Grant

Farm640

bottom of page