#165 Can You Farm on $200 Per Acre?


SW Financial Literacy
Can You Farm on $200 Per Acre?
A producer has averaged just $50 per acre in annual net worth gains over the past three years, so we know that the farm is barely getting ahead. They also want to buy a quarter of ground and insist on putting in a bid no matter what.
They do not have enough working capital to make any type of down payment, so they would have to finance 100% of the purchase price. Once you factor in the loan payment and property taxes, it would be $600 per acre in payments per year.
They were confident they could make that work. I let them know that they would essentially be paying me, the bank, $600 per acre per year in cash rent for the next 30 years on this property. They said they could improve the yields on the farm and make it happen.
But I wasn't convinced.
The Bank Is Your Landlord
Let's look at the numbers.
Annual expense | Per acre | 160 acres |
Principal and interest payments | $540 | $86,400 |
Property taxes | $60 | $9,600 |
Total annual payments | $600 | $96,000 |
That's $96,000 per year before you plant a single seed.
Now, I know it's not technically cash rent. Part of the principal payment builds equity, and eventually the loan will be paid off. But from a cash flow standpoint, that $600 per acre has to leave the operation every single year.
Whether corn is $3.50 or $5.00, whether you raise 150 bushels or 250 bushels, that payment is still due. And if you're financing 100% of the purchase price, you have very little flexibility when things don't go according to plan.
Can You Farm on $200?
The producer continued to believe they could make the payments by improving yields and generating additional revenue.
Finally, I pulled out a calculator and calculated the gross income per acre that the farm produced. We decided $800 per acre was acceptable.
Revenue and payments | Per acre | 160 acres |
Projected gross crop revenue | $800 | $128,000 |
Annual ownership payments | ($600) | |
Remaining for crop expenses and profit | $200 | $32,000 |
I then turned to the producer and asked if they could raise a decent crop on $200 per acre. Because that would be all that is left after they pay me rent.
That $200 per acre has to cover seed, fertilizer, chemicals, crop insurance, fuel, machinery expenses, repairs, and every other cost associated with raising the crop. We haven't even talked about generating a profit yet.
How much are you spending on fertilizer and chemicals alone? What about seed or the cost of running equipment across those acres? It doesn't take long to realize that $200 per acre isn't going to go very far.
And remember, this operation has only averaged $50 per acre in net worth gains over the past three years. Where exactly is the additional money supposed to come from?
Three Years of Minimal Growth
The first problem wasn't necessarily the price of the farm. It was the financial position of the operation trying to buy it.
This producer has averaged just $50 per acre in annual net worth gains over the past three years. That tells me the operation is making some financial progress, but very little. Maybe they're paying their bills and replacing equipment, but at the end of each year, they're only slightly further ahead financially.
Now they want to add a $600 per acre annual obligation to an operation that has only been growing net worth by $50 per acre. The operation can make $200 per acre cash rent work with a $50 per acre profit, but digging a hole of $350 per acre for a brand new farm will quickly take the operation from barely profitable to consistent losses. The margin for error would be gone.
They believe their existing acres can help support the new farm, but those acres have only generated modest financial gains. If the operation is already struggling to build working capital, where is the additional money going to come from?
I'm a big believer in buying farmland. I've purchased several farms myself, and I understand the desire to own more ground. But if you're barely building working capital or growing net worth on the acres you already farm, what makes you believe adding another 160 acres with an enormous payment will improve your financial position?
Sometimes Walking Away Wins
I understand wanting to own more land. I've been to auctions where I desperately wanted to buy a particular farm, and I've been outbid on farms I thought I would own for the rest of my life. It isn't easy to walk away, especially when it's the farm next door or a property you've rented for years.
But none of those things change the math.
That doesn't mean you should never stretch yourself financially to buy farmland. There are times when taking on additional risk makes sense, especially with a strong balance sheet, adequate working capital, and a realistic plan for making the payments.
But there's a difference between stretching yourself financially and putting your entire operation at risk.
The goal isn't to buy every farm that comes available. It's to be financially strong enough to buy the right one when the opportunity presents itself.
Sometimes the best land purchase you make is the one you don't make.
Can you raise a decent crop on $200 per acre?
Have a great week!
Grant




